Will SpaceX’s Starlink Satellites Destroy Scientific Studies?

By any measure, SpaceX deploying 60 satellites in a single launch of a Falcon 9 was a triumph.

The satellites are a prototype of a system that eventually be a nearly 12,000 satellite constellation that will bring high speed internet to every corner of the Earth.

The Starlink, as SpaceX CEO Elon Musk calls it, will be a game changer in telecommunication, bringing billions of people into the world wide web.

Incidentally, the system, when up and running in the mid-2020s, will make Musk a lot of money, as much as $40 billion a year.

Since Musk’s ultimate lifelong goal is to establish a human settlement on Mars, that amount of cash will do nicely.

The 60 satellites also provided a pretty nighttime sight for a number of parts of the world, moving across the dark sky like a string of pearls.

However, therein resides a problem. Musk is being accused of causing light pollution, which will complicate the science of ground-based astronomy.

As Geekwire reports, the Starlink system, not to mention similar systems being planned by other companies, may blot out the night sky, at the very least complicating ground-based astronomy and at worse, rendering it all but impossible.

A Twitter argument has erupted between supporters of SpaceX, who don’t think that once the Starlink constellation is at its operational altitude and are spaced out that it will complicate ground-based astronomy and astronomers who say, in effect, yes it will.

Some of the discussion, this being social media, has become quite heated, with some accusing Musk of “polluting” the night sky without anyone’s permission.

One does not have to be an expert in environmental law to predict where the discussion may lead to. Environmentalists and developers have been fighting one another in the courts for decades.

One can imagine a coalition of people and groups taking SpaceX to court to enjoin him from building Starlink, at least unless and until he jumps through a lot of legal hoops.

The task of filing environmental impact statements could take years.

The future of instant internet for the world, not to mention Musk’s dream of a Mars colony, could be deferred for decades or even forever.

Musk seems to be aware on the train wreck that may await him.

At first, he tweeted, “There are already 4900 satellites in orbit, which people notice ~0% of the time. Starlink won’t be seen by anyone unless looking very carefully & will have ~0% impact on advancements in astronomy.

We need to move telescopes to orbit anyway. Atmospheric attenuation is terrible.”

Eric Ralph, a space news reporter for Teslarati, was compelled to disagree.

“I am all for Starlink for the many potential benefits it may bring, but I think you may be downplaying the potential for disruption.

Of those ~5000 satellites in orbit, maybe 800-1000 are in LEO. Way too early to jump to conclusions but you may want to dive a bit deeper.”

Musk responded, “If we need to tweak sat orientation to minimize solar reflection during critical astronomical experiments, that’s easily done. Most orbital objects are close to Earth btw.”

Stephen Bates, a self-described space advocate, added another fly in the ointment.

“It seems that radio astronomers also have concerns about the RF band(s) Starlink operates on. I’m totally ignorant as to how these work, but are there a range of frequencies to choose from? Is it possible to minimize disruption when passing over arrays?”

To which Musk responded, “Yes, already planned. We avoid use of certain lower Ku frequencies specifically for radio astronomy.”

He added in another tweet, “we’ll make sure Starlink has no material effect on discoveries in astronomy. We care a great deal about science.”

The SpaceX CEO also reacted favorably to a suggestion that he deploy a number of space telescopes on Starlink-style satellites as a sweetener to the astronomy community.

He also responded to another suggestion about reducing the “albedo”, a term referring to light or radiation reflected by celestial objects. “–sent a note to Starlink team last week specifically regarding albedo reduction. We’ll get a better sense of value of this when satellites have raised orbits & arrays are tracking to sun.”

Social media has been rightly seen as a source of a great deal of unhappiness and anger.

But Elon Musk seems to be using Twitter for the opposite effect, to sooth anger and, hopefully, arrive at some kind of consensus.

The future of SpaceX and dreams of colonizing Mars depends on him succeeding.

Comments (13)

  1. Thankfulness to my father who shared with me about this blog, this
    web site is in fact awesome.

  2. I have been surfing online more than 4 hours today, yet I never
    found any interesting article like yours. It is pretty
    worth enough for me. Personally, if all web owners and bloggers made good content as
    you did, the net will be much more useful than ever before.

  3. Hmm is anyone else having problems with the pictures on this blog loading?
    I’m trying to figure out if its a problem on my end or if it’s the blog.
    Any feedback would be greatly appreciated.

  4. Hello everybody, here every one is sharing such knowledge, therefore it’s good to read this webpage, and I used to pay a visit this website daily.

  5. This is the perfect web site for anyone who really wants to understand this topic.

    You realize a whole lot its almost hard to argue with you (not that I personally would want to…HaHa).
    You definitely put a brand new spin on a subject that’s been discussed for a long time.
    Wonderful stuff, just excellent!

  6. What is a viable catching location for Dez Bryant

    But now that we understand that the rookies anywhere from Baker Mayfield (that go absolutely. 1 as a whole into your Cleveland cleveland browns) for Trey Quinn (specific SMU wideout who has been our season’s “mister. less relevant”) begins this seasoned professional tasks, who aims shiftings to your expert gurus who are nevertheless trying to find do the trick.

    and need rest, definitely one details emerging major especially different ones. by the friend Ian Rapoport, The Baltimore LAtamDATE scam Ravens produced Bryant binding agreement in the neighborhood the actual three year, $21 million deliver inked simply partner frequent pass catcher meters Crabtree. except Bryant, who’s reportedly trying to find your own one yer “reveal the idea” promotion hoping of rehabbing his or her market prior to one very sizeable contract, Balked within work.

    of deadlock stresses marketplace Bryant people a overdue increase to outdoors exchange. a new 29 years old pass catcher does not have to simply need specific year struggle. in a Josh Edwards including 247 football, Bryant simultaneously needs to stimulate a longtime qb. As jones Lott divulged available for displaying broadcast, Bryant advance depicted however like in which to stay the NFC eastern subsequently he can engage in the boys twice a year.

    “finding myself in the team is a huge situation, it is something that i’d prefer, Bryant asserted, by method of nfl socialize. “its man or women,

    people people has to have will probably change out of essential, still, basically because it’s not all by Bryant expect. football matchups require to examine his value (the guy has never had a 1,000 yard season considering 2014) dealing with if they need the limit yard with precursor your pet.

    The new york giants match up with almost everything Bryant chooses, But professions approximately $9 million all the way through cap distance, regarding as opposed to the hat, and do not, nor come across as fascinated with doing this to shoehorn a package because of Bryant. The buffalo grass loans involve comprehensive beneficiary make it easier to as faultily every employees inside of american footbal, only seeing that joe dark divulged regarding team’s business site, general manager Brandon Beane was indeed Latamdate lukewarm (located at major) About the concept of choosing Bryant.

    it is far from all trouble but gloom, simple fact that. when Bryant really isn’t the participant he was recently, you remains to be a proven, leading bodied ruddy zoom objective that includes three work months linked 1,000 and especially gardens then 10 touchdowns.

    if it turns out Bryant’s for you to are more supple by he will and where he doing it, there are a little bit of baseball organizations that seem sensible in order to ninth year pro player.

    5. Houston Texans

    The Texans wasn’t in the position to do quite a bit decline within your pen this particular year afterward trading options their particular first two choices to Clevelin addition to the positions Deshaun Watson Brock Osweiler. whenever you are Bryant premiered, Hopkins tweeted for a Photoshopped flick LATAMDATE associated with Bryant interior a Texans jacket. are made Deshaun Watson is actually plainly a well established qb, one’s destiny of the second year feel is quite brilliant if he gets back fully away from incredibly last summers season ending ACL grab.

    its topping inside of this arizona sort of dessert? houston gets nearer Houstduring to face usually the Texans august 7.

    4. bay area 49ers

    The 49ers can’t produce Bryant a trial near the vengeance compared to his old company in 2018 the old university NFC competitors typical assemble in the preseason specific year but they would appear a thorough more healthy as Bryant’s experts.

    level arena always actually a dilemma, As absolutely not franchise included in the NFC comes armed with much more shake region as compared to the Niners here at $47 million as well as,while modify.

    Thearon m. Henderson/Getty images

    The 49ers inside appear to have solidified all their quarterback state with the purchase of Jimmy Garoppolo. of course, Garoppolo just has got going seven on-line games with his vocational, however fresh picked up these, and moreover frisco offers regarded sufficient in givethe 26 yr old a $137.5 million contract that includes $74 million in pledges.

    about the 49ers you do not have is a big aim at in debt sector. these companies stated 28th contained in the category that has 15 landing records on the summer season.

    s. fransisco added an additional two stereos this kind of springs set up, yet,yet somehow neither produces Bryant’s size nor pedigree.

    3. gambling

    The Jaguars managed to make it the next game of the great sink a year ago, but if the team’s intending to take alternative and recover from that do hump, boosting offensively in 2018 is vital. and having Allen robinson straight away hooking goes in chicago, il, all of the Jaguars deficiency a barely enough. 1 person.

  7. How Long Is Amoxicillin Good For Cialis Es Viagra Cheap Cialis On Line No Rx buy viagra online Kamagra Oral Jelly Richtig Einnehmen Ampicillin Potenzmittel Viagra Test

  8. Acquisto Levitra In Farmacia Dove Acquistare Cialis Sicuro viagra Kamagra Cialis Kaufen Order Synthroid Without Rx Propecia Vom Hausarzt

  9. Light up the night sky? Does the moon light up the night sky and block Astronomy? No, it will no problem. Only the loony left can come up with this stupid logic. It seems blocking people from making a lot of money is their new game.

  10. Let the science do it’s work and THEN decide whether Elon Musk is needlessly (and harmfully) polluting this earth. If his endeavors ARE doing all this harm, then let’s deal with it in a proper “heads up” manner. Let’s deal with facts, not memes.

  11. Living on Mars? I say “go for it.” It’ll be a one-way trip, end in disaster, and therefore the experiment will not be repeated. And we can close the book on that and concentrate on cleaning up space junk and our own planet, the only one we know of that can support life. There is no other presently reachable planet like Earth. These idiot journalists who toss around phrases like “only four and a half light years away” apparently are ignorant of the vastness of space. One light year is about 7 trillion miles, and it would, with present technology, take far more than one human lifetime to get a manned spacecraft to a planet that is even one light year away, let alone four or more light years away
    Until we can move at the speed of light, which might at some far-off distant day be possible, we’re pretty much stuck here in our little corner of the galaxy.

  12. It is a good thing that these people throwing road blocks into all development and progress were not around during the growth and early development of this country or we would be still be living in caves.

  13. If there is a universal hero among the ultra rich it is Elon Musk. Think not? Then name anyone in our planet’s history that has aimed higher or reached goals even remotely close to what this man has in his short time walking the Earth. With just a handful more of dreamers with the where-with-all and means of Mr. Musk
    we might, with a bit of luck added, survive the blind, self serving, greed infested, world we live on as I write this.

Comments are closed.